"Switching health insurer always means paying less"

Five common misconceptions about switching health insurer, checked against priminfo and the LAMal (Swiss Federal Health Insurance Act).

GoLamal - "Switching health insurer always means paying less"

Introduction: why this myth resurfaces every autumn

Premiums are published at the end of September. From October onwards, letters from comparison sites and insurers land in letterboxes, all carrying the same message: switch before 30 November. The reflex is understandable. According to the FOPH (Federal Office of Public Health), the average premium for an adult in Switzerland exceeds CHF 350 per month (to be checked on priminfo.admin.ch for 2026), or more than CHF 4200 per year.
But this national figure masks very wide gaps between cantons, premium regions, deductibles and insurance models. Five claims come up again and again. Here is what the LAMal and the priminfo data say about each of them.

"Switching insurer always saves money"

FALSE. The saving depends on your starting point. If you are already with an insurer close to the bottom of the ranking in your premium region, the gain is nil, or even negative after a change of model or deductible.
Within a single premium region, the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive insurer reaches several hundred francs per year for an adult with the same deductible and the same model. The official comparison tool priminfo.admin.ch lets you measure it for your exact situation.
The deductible also weighs in the balance. In Geneva, the average premium for an adult with a CHF 300 deductible exceeds CHF 450 per month, compared with less than CHF 330 in Appenzell Innerrhoden. Moving from a CHF 300 to a CHF 2500 deductible reduces the monthly premium by several tens of francs, but you bear up to CHF 2200 of additional costs per year if you need care. This is not a guaranteed saving; it is a bet on your medical consumption.
Switching insurer is therefore only worthwhile if the annual gap exceeds what you lose elsewhere (care network, service, model). Always compare at identical deductible and model, in CHF per year, before deciding.
For a broader view of the subject, see our analysis on how to lower your basic premium, which details the levers beyond simply changing insurer.

"You must switch before 30 November, otherwise it is impossible"

PARTLY TRUE. For basic insurance, the general rule requires termination effective 31 December, with a letter received by the insurer no later than 30 November, according to the health insurance ordinance and the indications of priminfo.admin.ch. For an adult with the standard deductible (CHF 300) and a standard model, this is the key date.
Two important nuances. First, a change of model or deductible follows deadlines that may differ. A higher deductible can generally be chosen before the end of November, whereas a lower deductible is subject to rules specific to each insurer. Alternative models (family doctor, HMO, Telmed) sometimes involve a minimum commitment period. Check your general terms and conditions.
Second, there is an extraordinary termination right. If your insurer announces a premium increase, you have one month from receipt of the letter to terminate, with effect on 31 December or, depending on the case, at the end of the month following termination. The insurer must inform you of this possibility.
Beware of the last-day trap: the letter must have reached the insurer, not merely have been posted on 30 November. Send it by registered mail, with a margin of several days.
For the full procedure, our guide to terminating your health insurance before 30 November details the steps.

"By switching insurer, you lose your rights or risk being refused"

FALSE for basic insurance. Under Art. 4 LAMal, every insurer is obliged to accept any person required to be insured, with no health questionnaire, no reservation and no waiting period. Basic benefits are identical with all insurers, because they are set by law. Free movement between insurers is guaranteed.
Your state of health, your age or your medical history have no effect on acceptance in basic insurance. Only the premium varies, according to premium region, age category (child, young adult, adult), deductible and model.
The contrast with supplementary insurance is stark. Supplementary insurance falls under the Insurance Contract Act (LCA), not the LAMal. The insurer may impose a health questionnaire, issue reservations, set a surcharge or simply refuse the application.
In other words, changing insurer for basic cover carries no risk of exclusion. Changing for supplementary cover carries a real one. This is the central factual distinction of the whole subject, and the source of most misunderstandings.
Obligation to accept

Basic insurance (LAMal)

Yes: the insurer must accept any person required to be insured (Art. 4 LAMal)

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

No: the insurer chooses

Health questionnaire

Basic insurance (LAMal)

Prohibited

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

Possible

Reservations or surcharges

Basic insurance (LAMal)

None

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

Possible

Refusal possible

Basic insurance (LAMal)

No

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

Yes

Benefits

Basic insurance (LAMal)

Identical with all insurers, set by law

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

Vary according to the insurer

Risk linked to switching

Basic insurance (LAMal)

None

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

Real: lost cover can rarely be recovered on the same terms

Contract

Basic insurance (LAMal)

Separate contract: terminating basic insurance does not terminate supplementary insurance

Supplementary insurance (LCA)

Separate contract: terminating supplementary insurance changes nothing about basic insurance

Basic: acceptance guaranteed for everyone. Supplementary: the insurer may refuse

Key takeaway

Changing insurer for basic cover carries no risk of exclusion, but for supplementary cover, obtain the new insurer's written acceptance before terminating the old policy.
Source: Art. 4 LAMal (basic insurance); Insurance Contract Act, LCA (supplementary insurance) — fedlex.admin.ch; priminfo.admin.ch

"A termination letter is enough to change everything, supplementary

FALSE. Basic insurance and supplementary insurance are two separate contracts, governed by two different laws (LAMal and LCA). Terminating one does not terminate the other.
A letter terminating your basic insurance does not end your supplementary policies. Conversely, terminating the supplementary policy changes nothing about your basic affiliation. Each contract has its own deadlines and its own formal requirements.
The main risk concerns supplementary insurance. If you terminate it before obtaining a firm offer elsewhere, you may find yourself without supplementary cover. The new insurer is not obliged to accept you: a health questionnaire, reservation or refusal all remain possible. Cover lost at age 55 can rarely be recovered on the same terms.
Safe procedure:
  • First obtain the new insurer's written acceptance for the supplementary cover.
  • Then terminate the old one, by registered letter, within the deadline set by your contract.
  • For basic insurance, the new insurer can handle the termination with the old one, but keep proof of dispatch.
A letter terminating supplementary insurance must state your policy number and the desired effective date, and must be signed. Without prior agreement elsewhere, do not send it.

"The subsidy follows automatically when you change insurer"

PARTLY TRUE. The individual premium reduction is a cantonal benefit, set out in Art. 65 LAMal: cantons must reduce the premiums of insured persons of modest economic means. The entitlement does not depend on your insurer, but practical implementation depends on the canton.
In Fribourg, for example, the health insurance subsidy is administered by the Caisse cantonale de compensation (cantonal compensation fund) and paid directly to the insurer, which deducts it from your invoices. When you change insurer, the payment must be redirected to the new insurer. In other cantons, the amount is paid to the beneficiary, who pays the premium in full.
What you need to check:
  • If a subsidy application is already under way or has been accepted, notify the competent cantonal office of the change of insurer.
  • If you have never applied for a subsidy, check your entitlement: the threshold depends on the household's determining income. The canton of Vaud, for example, grants a reduction as soon as the premium exceeds 10% of the determining income.
  • Check the new insurer's first invoice to make sure the deduction appears.
Filing rules, deadlines and amounts differ from one canton to another. Enquire with your cantonal office before the end of November, because a change that is not properly notified can delay payment by several months.

Key takeaways

  • End of September: check your insurer's 2026 premium on priminfo.admin.ch and compare at identical deductible, model and premium region, in CHF per year.
  • Before 30 November: if you change basic insurance, the termination letter must reach the insurer within the deadline. Send it by registered mail with a margin.
  • After a premium increase announcement: you have one month from receipt of the letter to terminate, even outside the usual calendar.
  • Supplementary insurance: never terminate before you have written acceptance from the new insurer.
  • Subsidy: notify the cantonal office of the change of insurer so that the individual premium reduction is redirected.
"The information in this article is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a personalised recommendation; golamal.ch is registered with FINMA under number F01502264, and it is your responsibility to check your situation with your insurer before any change."

FAQ

For basic insurance, the termination must in principle reach the insurer before 30 November for effect on 31 December. If a premium increase is announced, you have one month from receipt of the insurer's letter.

No. Under Art. 4 LAMal, the insurer must accept any person required to be insured, with no health questionnaire or reservation. This principle does not apply to LCA supplementary insurance, where refusal remains possible.

No. They are two separate contracts, governed by the LAMal and the LCA. Each must be terminated separately, within its own deadlines, and you must obtain the new insurer's acceptance before leaving the old supplementary policy.

Entitlement to the individual premium reduction depends on the canton, not on the insurer. However, notify the cantonal office of the change, because payment is often sent directly to the insurer and must be redirected.

Use the official comparison tool priminfo.admin.ch, run by the FOPH. Always compare at identical premium region, deductible, model and age category, and express the gap in CHF per year.

Compare before 30 November

An analysis of your current premium, deductible and model will tell you whether switching is really worthwhile in your premium region.

Author image
GoLamal Team

4 November 2026